Assignment #8 – Short Creek

1 13 2012 6038
In the bedroom of a former FLDS member, with a portrait of LeRoy Johnson on the wall

Really this was a series of assignments and I don’t know when they will be published, so these photos are outtakes that don’t really go with any of the stories. I’ll post more photos as the stories go live.

The situation in Short Creek (Colorado City and Hildale, two towns known for their polygamous residents) seems murky and in flux. We met lots of new people who are no longer members of Warren Jeffs’ FLDS church and heard their stories. We didn’t talk with any current FLDS members as they seem to have reverted back into quiet mode.

1 14 2012 4695

I always enjoy driving around the towns and soaking in the scenery. Sometimes you shoot and sometimes you don’t. A couple of scenes that I didn’t shoot… Three young girls running away when they saw our car (they seemed so scared). Young boy glaring at me in the open gate leading to his house (had to admire his spunk, he just stared me down as we drove slowly by).

Lots of stories, lots of secrets. After so long watching from afar, this trip reminded me how important the story is, and how the time we’ve invested in it so far has been very valuable. I’ll definitely be going back soon, either on assignment or on my own.

S094384

October 24, 2011

I finished Neal Stephenson’s 1,042 page Reamde: A Novel
. Instead of starting something else, I started in on some Scientology blogs. Well, anti-Scientology blogs actually.

So many parallels between the FLDS and Scientology scene. The blogs are similar as well. The big blog on the FLDS story gets hundreds of comments on most of its posts as regular readers trade information and theories. The anti-Scientology blogs are the same, like Mark Rathbun’s, http://markrathbun.wordpress.com/.

Like the FLDS, many who have left Scientology have become vocal in telling their stories. The most interesting of these are former leaders of Scientology, some who were in high positions and were complicit in many of the actions they now decry. It’s a fascinating thing to have someone turn. If they knew about and/or participated in the bad acts they now decry, how soon are they embraced as “good guys?” It’s something that would make a great story, FLDS-wise. Haven’t read it yet.

Another thing that sucked me in last night is something I wish we had done with the FLDS story. The Village Voice ran a series on their Runnin Scared blog listing the Top 25 People Crippling Scientology. The series gives you a great insight into who is who in the Scientology debate, both for and against. Of course, it’s written in a heavily biased tone.

It would be a fun exercise to write a list like that about the FLDS, in a more objective manner. Get into the characters. The people who are the story. Or the issues that are ongoing. You could easily do the Top 25 ongoing legal actions in the FLDS story.

Maybe I’ll do it myself. Why wait? The phone certainly ain’t ringing.

.:.

And make sure you check out this one… #19 on the list of people crippling Scientology… The Squirrel Busters. They’re camped out in front of Rathbun’s home, sending a message…

That was in April. Now, in late August, the Squirrel Busters are still there, sitting outside Rathbun’s house every day in a golf cart, filming him and filming themselves, hoping to get a rise out of Rathbun or goad him into assaulting them.

August 1, 2011

Interesting blog post by Mike Watkiss, a reporter who has covered polygamy and the FLDS for a long time, entitled Whatever happens to Warren Jeff (sic)– the media Is already guilty. He says…

after the initial “Oh My God–What is this place?–And look what cops have done” reaction; followed by the even bigger “Oh My God–look at all the kids the cops are taking out of there” response, the media then settled into it’s traditional role in this story of being gullible and dumb.

…and…

I think I’m the only reporter in the country that didn’t get on to the Ranch in the aftermath of the raid. But hey, if I was that guy, I would not have invited me to their party either. I would have asked questions that would have spoiled the sympathetic love-fest.

As for me, I’ve written and erased about several dozen lines just now, trying and failing to say the things I want to say. I’m sure I’ll keep revising this text.

I’ve worked next to Watkiss on several big stories. I think he’s right that tough questions need to be asked, always.

There have been many “media campaigns” over the past ten years of the FLDS story, from both sides. The challenge for any journalist is to look at each one, no matter who is pushing it, with a critical view and try to get to the truth of the situation without personal bias.

Doing tough reporting while at the same time trying to gain access to sources is a dilemma for journalists everywhere.

If you aren’t a skeptical reader/viewer checking in on a variety of media sources…and I guess even if you are…it’s hard to know what’s really going on.

Obviously I’m not in Texas right now. I’m watching from home. Do I regret that I’m not there? Of course. I was so involved in covering this story for so long, as much more than a photographer. At least it’s not 106 degrees here at my house.

Lots of institutional knowledge sitting here in my office unused, not the least of which is a list of restaurants to avoid in San Angelo.

.:.

You can follow Lindsay’s twitter feed from the Warren Jeffs trial here:
@lwhitehurst

WOW!!!! This is SO exciting!!! But I am not a Polygamist

I’m getting a laugh out of having to say this:

I am not posing as a polygamist wife. I am not Honey Dawn.

A few months ago a new blog went up allegedly written by a plural wife named (Honey Dawn). From the first post it was completely ridiculous, written in excited-mommy blogger style and riddled with intentional misspellings. Here’s a sample:

WOW!!!! This is SO exciting!!! My first blog!! Pratt says I should REALLY write this becuse Im so clever about writing things down. He says I should write a book about how to live Celestial Plural marriage (the right name for polygamy, which is TOO nasty a word!) so Im just putting down my ideas to help people know what a fun way this is to live, and how very HOLY it is too.

Recently someone claimed to have tracked Honey Dawn’s blog to a Tribune IP address. (Which isn’t possible; it’s a Blogspot blog. Blogspot is run by Google. Only Google would know the IP of the blogger.)

Next came comments guessing that I was behind the whole thing, writing as Honey Dawn.

Sorry, but it just isn’t the case. It would be unethical of me to do this while covering polygamy and I can’t see doing it even if I weren’t. My credibility is more important to me than writing a Big Love knock-off. And anyway, I would definitely write it from the guy’s point of view. Way more angles.

2008 UEP Hearing – The Exit

11.12.2008 12571.jpg

Now everyone is inside the federal court (no cameras allowed) and the hearing is presumably going on. Standing out front it’s hard to know what’s happening. You don’t. It’s time to wait. And while we wait it is getting dark outside. Really dark.

The hearing ends. A few TV cameras stand by and film the large group of FLDS as they stream out of the court and onto the sidewalk. A couple of them give short responses to questions from the cameras.

11.12.2008 13181.jpg
11.12.2008 13471.jpg
11.12.2008 1314.jpg

They go off in all directions and I don’t bother chasing anyone down. The photo I want needs to have the courthouse in the background.

11.12.2008 1384.jpg